Chess, stress and anxiety: a game that calms or one that raises tension?
Chess and anxiety sometimes go well together, sometimes not. Physiological measurements show that a competitive game activates the nervous system’s stress response: heart rate rises, and its variability falls when the position becomes complicated. A relaxed game among friends is a different experience. No study has shown that chess reduces anxiety.
Heart rate variability: small variations in the interval between two heartbeats. It reflects the balance between the sympathetic nervous system (the accelerator, linked to stress) and the parasympathetic (the brake, linked to rest); it generally decreases when mental load or stress increases.
Chess and anxiety: what physiology measures
Two teams have measured what happens in a player’s body while they think. The first, French, equipped club players during real games.
Troubat et al., 2009 · European Journal of Applied Physiology · DOI 10.1007/s00421-008-0908-2
The stress of chess players as a model to study the effects of psychological stimuli on physiological responses
- Who
- 20 club players (men)
- Type
- Physiological study during games · level of evidence: Low (descriptive)
- Result
- During the game, heart rate rises to 75-86 beats per minute and the balance of the nervous system tilts towards sympathetic activation; the body gradually shifts from carbohydrates to fats as fuel.
- What the study does not say
- Small male group; does not measure an expenditure of several thousand calories.
The authors interpret these changes as the response to a high cognitive demand, and propose chess as a model for studying the effects of psychological stress on the body. In other words: a serious game is a stress situation, modest but real.
The second study, Spanish, had players solve problems of increasing difficulty.
Fuentes-García et al., 2019 · Frontiers in Psychology · DOI 10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00409
Differences Between High vs. Low Performance Chess Players in Heart Rate Variability During Chess Problems
- Who
- 16 players (men)
- Type
- Cross-sectional experimental study · level of evidence: Low
- Result
- Heart rate variability falls when the problems become difficult; it stays higher in the players who solve the most problems.
- What the study does not say
- Very small sample; groups defined by success on the test, not by rating.
The best-performing players seem to cope better with mental load, which matches a familiar observation among competitors: experience teaches you to stay calm. But with sixteen participants, these results remain to be confirmed.
What these studies do not say
- That playing chess is bad for the heart: the rises measured are modest and passing.
- That chess would reduce anxiety in daily life: that was not their purpose.
- What women or older players experience: both studies concern only small groups of men.
6,000 calories a day: a contested estimate
In September 2019, an article by the American channel ESPN titled “The Grandmaster Diet” went around the world: a grandmaster would burn up to 6,000 calories a day in a tournament. The figure was attributed to the neurobiologist Robert Sapolsky, of Stanford University, who compared the players’ stress response to that of athletes.
This figure comes from no published study that measured it. Actual measurements, such as those by Troubat and colleagues, show a moderate rise in heart rate and a change in the body’s fuel, not an expenditure comparable to that of a long-distance runner. A metabolism researcher has also publicly challenged the estimate, for want of a supporting measurement. That players lose weight during a long tournament is plausible (stress, reduced appetite, irregular meals, sometimes physical exercise), but it does not mean that thinking burns thousands of calories.
This myth and others are examined on the page chess and health: 9 myths put to the test.
Is chess dangerous for your health?
No, no study shows it. Like any seated, absorbing activity, it simply calls for a few common-sense precautions:
- sitting still: long hours seated, at a tournament or online, are offset by physical activity;
- sleep: online games late in the evening, with a bright screen, can delay falling asleep;
- compulsive chaining: playing fast game after fast game following a defeat, to “win it back”, feeds frustration and fatigue;
- competitive pressure: for some players, particularly young ones, rating stakes become a source of anxiety; it is better to talk about it than to let it take hold.
Chess, mood and depression
In the French PAQUID cohort, older people who regularly played board games developed depression slightly less often during follow-up than the others. This is an association, observed in a study designed for dementia, and it weakens when baseline cognitive state is taken into account. It does not allow chess to be recommended against depression, which calls for medical support.
It is sometimes said that chess would act on depression through “neuroplasticity”. Brain plasticity is a real phenomenon, described on the page the chess player’s brain, but no study has shown that it would make chess effective against depression.
Playing to relax
To keep chess a pleasure rather than a source of tension:
- Choose slow games or games without a clock, with a friendly partner.
- Set yourself a limit on online games, and stop after two defeats in a row.
- Vary the pleasures: solve problems, replay a famous game, analyse with nothing at stake.
- Look after the setting: a clear table, good light, a board always ready. Le Palais des Échecs gives advice on setting up your chessboard in a quiet corner, the right way round and at a good height.
- Play with others: the social side often counts for more than the result.
See also: chess and ADHD, chess and autism.
Frequently asked questions
Is chess dangerous for your health?
No. No study shows any danger. A competitive game provokes a moderate, passing stress response; all that is needed is to offset sitting still with physical activity, protect your sleep and avoid playing game after game in the grip of frustration.
Does chess burn calories?
A little more than at rest, because of stress and concentration, but the figure of 6,000 calories per tournament day, popularised by an ESPN article in 2019, rests on no published measurement. Physiological studies show moderate rises in heart rate.